| |
WHITE PAPER FOR TECHNICAL BUFFS |
| |
|
 |
Magnan Type Vi and Signature
Cables |
| |
The
Magnan interconnects and speaker cables are the result of
years of research to develop the best possible audio cable
regardless of cost materials and labor. Through the use
of new and innovative techniques, the Magnan interconnects
and speaker cables drastically reduce audio band time smearing,
associated phase shifts, and low level noise. There is a
dramatic clarification of everything in the sound field
with much better image focus, depth and width, much finer
low level detail, and reduction of background noise. Highs
are much more detailed but smooth and natural, and lows
much more distinct and powerful. Multiple layers of congestion,
muddiness, blurring or smearing of image, and overbrightness
are removed and revealed to be interconnect and speaker
cable degradations that had always been assumed to be caused
by the electronics, speakers and recordings.
The philosophy of the designer, based on experience, is
that the ultimate subtlety and resolving power of human
hearing perception is vastly beyond present instrumentation
capability and acoustical/neurological theory. Nevertheless,
it has been very valuable to develop some understanding
of underlying phenomena so as to be able to predict the
most likely design approaches and material selections. The
development of the Magnan cable designs was made possible
by the discovery that the ear is very sensitive to the removal
or reduction of skin effect-caused time domain distortions
of the music signal occurring in the cables used in a music
system.
Of course, any recording already contains the time smearing
and distortion of many feet of conventional cables used
in recording, mixing and mastering. Despite this, the time
coherence of the few feet of cable used in playback is found
to be critical to the final reproduced sound quality. An
optical analogy is useful in understanding how this can
be. An example is a film projector. The film print is very
blurred and noisy because of film grain relative to the
original scene due to losses in the negative and many steps
of processing and duplication using imperfect lenses and
film. Despite the "program material" being noisy
and distorted, the image projected on the screen is still
obviously different and inferior when using a poor quality
projection lens when compared with a high quality lens.
The quality lens is superior because it is achromatic (no
color fringing and sharper focus) and because it has a flat
field (entire picture in focus) with little geometrical
distortion at the edges. The visual system easily detects
a small reduction or increase in distortion and noise in
an already distorted and noisy image. The auditory system
must be similar in this capability. This is a sophisticated
pattern detection ability and seems to be especially sensitive
to differences when the comparison is between two different
reproductions.
The skin effect phenomenon has been found to be the major
signal degrading effect in conventional audio cables. These
effects include smearing of musical details, smearing together
of instrumental images, flattening of the sound stage, and
usually a general overbrightness. Almost all conventional
audio cables utilize relatively thick stranded or solid
wires which inherently cause gross audio band skin effect
time smearing. Even the existing ribbon designs are far
too thick to significantly reduce the problem. The conclusion
that skin effect is of preeminent importance in audio cables
is based on lengthy experimentation with different conductors.
The second most important problem parameter has been found
to be dielectric absorption, primarily with interconnect
cables. This is also addressed in the Magnan interconnects
through use of a TFE Teflon/air space construction. Distortion
introduced by the dielectric absorption in most plastic
insulation materials is also a form of time smearing of
the signal waveform which points again to the great sensitivity
of the ear to time-related distortions. Many other commonly
used parameters in audio cable design have been found to
be either relatively unimportant or not applicable at audio
frequencies. Examples are extreme conductor metal purity
and characteristic impedance.
The physics of skin effect phase shift in wires have been
well known for many years. A change in driving voltage causes
a corresponding change in the electric field which is propagated
almost instantaneously from source to load in the space
around the conductor. The skin effect is physically caused
by the frequency dependent attenuation and slowing down
of the induced signal current as it penetrates into and
propagates through the conductor. The higher the frequency
the more the current is attenuated and slowed with depth
from the surface, to the point where at RF almost all the
signal current is concentrated in a thin "skin".
The voltage generated at the load termination of the cable
at an amplifier input, for example, is what actually controls
the amplifier. This voltage is proportional to the total
instantaneous signal current passed by the cable into the
load. Since the signal current is stretched out in time,
the signal voltage at the cable load or amp input is identically
degraded.
The key to the detail and image smearing caused by this
phenomenon is the fact that the part of a music signal at
any given frequency is also smeared or spread out slightly
in time. The signal current at any frequency is propagated
through the entire conductor with the slowing, corresponding
time delay and attenuation increasing continuously from
surface to center. The leading edge of a signal arrives
nearly instantaneously at the load, but it is always followed
by a slight "shadow" or time-smeared replica.
In addition, since the high frequencies predominantly arrive
slightly earlier than the mid and bass frequencies, the
sensitivity of the ear to early arrival sounds causes an
apparent overbrightness.
The total music signal, composed of many different frequency
components, is also slightly smeared out in time with the
highs arriving slightly early. In conventional wire and
cable this effect is so severe to the ear-brain system that
it destroys a multitude of small but important sonic details,
resulting in the blurring and flattening of soundstage muddiness,
etc., described previously. The magnitude of the skin effect
at any given frequency can be defined as the width in time
of the signal waveform smearing. This time spread at any
frequency is determined by the maximum distance the signal
current can penetrate into the conductor (i.e., half the
thickness), and by the maximum phase shift and attenuation
which occurs at that depth. The more resistive the conductor
material the less the attenuation and slowing of the wave
as it penetrates and the smaller the maximum attenuation
and slowing. Therefore, the thinner and more resistive the
conductor, the less the skin effect caused time smearing
and the greater the sonic resolution. No limit has yet been
found to this relationship - no matter how thin or resistive
the conductor is made it continues to improve the sound.
This principle is the basis of the design of the Magnan
interconnect and speaker cables.
Magnan Audio Cables has derived a "figure of merit"
which in one number relates conductor thickness and conductor
resistivity directly to the perceived sonic resolution of
the wire when used in an audio cable. The larger the figure
of merit the lower the time dispersion due to the conductor
and the better the time and musical resolution. Listening
evaluations of experimental cables using a large variety
of different conductor materials and thicknesses have been
conducted and have invariably verified the principle and
calculated figure of merit as long as the conductor is nonmagnetic.
These experiments have verified the principle that the greater
the skin effect of a cable, the worse the time smearing,
overbrightness and other degradations to the sound.
The data is graphically displayed in Figure 1. The figures
of merit are relative to the performance of 20 gage copper
wire, which is set equal to 1. A log vertical scale (1,
10, 100, 1000, etc.) is used, corresponding much more closely
to actual hearing perception than a linear scale. As could
be expected from the relative conductor performance figures,
the Magnan Audio Cables achieve dramatic audible improvements
over conventional cables |
| |
|
| |
It was
found that skin effect in the ground conductor of a single
ended cable (RCA-RCA) also causes significant audible degradation
since it returns the signal current to the source. Consequently,
the ground return needs to have as small skin effect as
possible along with low DC resistance to prevent hum. With
the Type Vi this design parameter is achieved through use
of a very thin copper foil strip ground return. An optimally
thin metallized conductor is used in the Signature interconnects.
Use of a very thin high resistivity wire conductor is the
least difficult and expensive construction minimizing skin
effect. The Magnan Type Vi interconnects push the thin metal
wire design approach as far as possible, using a 5/10,000
inch thick high resistivity bronze ribbon. The sonic results
are transparency, ambience retrieval, image focus and soundstage
size beyond any conventional cables using "normal"
relatively thick wire. The Type Vi cables are completely
handmade and are handsome in appearance, with a black braided
nylon cloth jacket and label in gold and blue with directional
arrow. Diameter is approximately 3/8'' (RCA) and 1/2'' (XLR).
A metal wire or ribbon can be made only just so thin before
it becomes impossibly expensive to manufacture and too weak
and delicate to utilize in a cable. The Magnan Signature
interconnect cables drastically reduce skin effect caused
degradations beyond the level achieved by the Type Vi using
a proprietary high resistance nonmetallic conductor in the
form of a very thin coating of conductive plastic "paint"
on a wide plastic ribbon substrate. The high resistivity
(thousands of ohms) of the coating further greatly reduces
the skin effect time dispersion of the conductor. Also,
the use of a nonmetallic, amorphous polymer conductor confers
a large additional audible benefit in terms of greatly reduced
background noise due to the absence of metal crystal grain
boundaries and other discontinuities in the signal path.
To give some idea of the actual conductor dimensions involved,
Figure 2 illustrates to scale the relative sizes of a fairly
small conventional wire, a human hair, and the bronze ribbon
conductor used in the Magnan Type Vi. The conductive plastic
coating used in the Signature interconnect cable is 2-3
times as thick as the Type Vi bronze ribbon, but has thousands
of times the resistivity of the bronze. |
| |
|
| |
The total design of the Signature cable is complex and
involves many tradeoffs resulting from the physics of
materials and the constraints imposed by actual interfacing
circuits. The key factor involved is that high resistance
(thousands of ohms) is inherent in the conductor in order
to achieve very low skin effect in the audio band with
correspondingly very high time resolution. The better
the time resolution performance the thinner and more resistive
must be the signal conductor. The large resistance necessary
for high time resolution in the Signature interconnect
creates several interrelated performance tradeoffs which
establish practical limits to achievable cable time resolution.
The primary tradeoff is between cable time resolution
and overall system gain. The cable signal conductor resistance
in conjunction with amplifier, etc. load input impedance
creates a voltage divider which reduces gain. As an example,
a 50,000 ohm cable into a 50,000 ohm input impedance at
the amplifier would result in a 6 dB power or volume loss.
Another constraint on maximum achievable cable time resolution
(i.e. on maximum allowable cable resistance) is the fact
that the cable resistance in conjunction with cable internal
capacitance plus load input circuit capacitance and load
input resistance form a low pass filter. The maximum allowable
cable resistance and load input resistance must be limited
so as to keep this high frequency roll off well above
the audio band. With tube input circuits the input grid
capacitance will probably be greater than the cable capacitance,
due to the so-called Miller effect where interelectrode
tube capacitance is amplified by the tube voltage gain.
Because of this, cable resistance needs to be limited
to approximately 35,000 ohms when the cable drives a tube
amplifier or other tube unit.
These tradeoffs have been worked out with the goal of
optimizing overall performance with most systems. The
Signature interconnect cable resistance is standardized
at 30,000 ohms (approximate). Most systems have enough
reserve gain to compensate for the resulting gain loss
of one pair. Longer than standard 4-foot length cables
utilize a wider ribbon and/or more layers to achieve the
same total resistance and net time resolution as the 4-foot
cable.
The Signature interconnect cables are terminated in short
(3 1/2'') small flexible leads ending in the RCA and XLR
connectors. Due to the basic design, most of the cable
length is of large diameter. The RCA-RCA version is approximately
7/8'' in diameter and the XLR-XLR version is 1 1/4'' in
diameter. Despite their bulk, the cables are flexible
due to use of convoluted Teflon tubing.
The best available connectors are used (based on listening
tests). Of necessity, the Magnan Signature interconnect
cables are completely handmade from the conductors out
and present an exotic, rich appearance using double layer
monofilament braid sleeving (translucent over black).
|
|
 |
Magnan Signature Speaker Cable |
| |
In the case of speaker cables, it is much more difficult
to greatly reduce audio band skin effect because of the
need to have high conductivity metal with large cross-sectional
area for low total resistance. Only one method has been
found to work well - the "brute force" approach
using a very thin, very wide copper ribbon with a resistance
of no more than approximately .003 ohms per foot. This low
a resistance is needed for good bass control and extension
due to the high drive currents and corresponding maximal
cable voltage drops involved.
It was found that this simple design requirement was by
far the most important for the speaker cable. The many other
parameters commonly used in speaker cable design were found
to be either relatively unimportant in the ribbon cable
or not applicable at audio frequencies. Examples are extreme
metal purity, dielectric material and characteristic impedance.
The resulting speaker cable is in the form of two separate
five-inch wide flat cables for each speaker. For best performance
the two separate flat cables driving a speaker should be
laid side by side where possible rather than on top of each
other. The physical appearance of the Magnan Signature Speaker
Cable is high-tech with a glossy black nylon woven jacket.
The cable termination design accomodates closely spaced,
hard-to-get-at speaker and amplifier binding posts by narrowing
the end 7'' down to a point to which is attached a short
flexible lead with the required spade lug or banana connector.
|
|
|
| CONTACT INFO |
Address: | Magnan Cables, Inc 355 No. Lantana #576, Camarillo, CA 93010-6038, USA |
Tel/Fax: | (805) 484-9544 |
E-mail: | magnaninfo0340@aol.com | |
|